McMahon's Public House

Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 39 5th Avenue, McMahon's Public House delivers an authentic Irish pub experience that perfectly blends time-honored tradition with a lively, contemporary vibe. This beloved Irish pub is a haven for those craving rich, hearty dishes paired with a comforting atmosphere that feels like a warm embrace after a long day.

The menu at McMahon’s is a masterclass in classic pub fare elevated by quality and care. Imagine sinking your teeth into crispy, golden Fish & Chips served with perfectly tartar sauce, or savoring the velvety richness of their Shepherd’s Pie, brimming with tender meat and topped with mashed potato clouds. Their Bangers and Mash is a standout—plump, juicy sausages resting on a mountain of creamy mashed potatoes, crowned with caramelized onions and a luscious brown gravy that wraps around your taste buds like a comforting hug.

Appetizers at McMahon’s are an irresistible gateway to the meal. The Public House Potato Bites, a unique creation of mashed potatoes loaded with cheese and green peas then fried to a crisp golden finish, come with their signature Guinness cheese sauce—a rich, indulgent dip that’s simply unforgettable. The Irish Egg Rolls, stuffed with house-brined corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, and melted Swiss cheese served alongside a zingy Russian dressing, offer a delicious twist on a traditional favorite.

Burgers and sandwiches here are equally tempting, from the juicy Classic Beef Burger crafted with an 8oz prime patty to the bold Spicy Habanero Burger, layered with pepper jack cheese and a fiery habanero bacon spread that ignites the palate. For lighter fare or classic comfort, the Full Irish Breakfast Plate serves up two eggs, rasher, sausages, black and white pudding, baked beans, grilled tomato, and home fries, all paired with your choice of toast—an ideal start to any morning or midday meal.

The drink selection at McMahon’s complements its menu perfectly. Whether you’re raising a pint of Guinness, enjoying a crisp cider, or indulging in finely crafted cocktails like the Old Fashioned with Knob Creek Rye, the bar is well-stocked and skilled. Patrons appreciative of top-shelf spirits will find delights like Balvenie or a shot of Hennessy VSOP to chase the evening perfectly.

Step inside McMahon's and you’re greeted by an inviting blend of warm wood tones, exposed brick, and nostalgic sports memorabilia that create an old-school charm and an inviting ambiance. Multiple screens ensure you never miss a live game, making it a vibrant gathering spot for friends and family alike. This is especially clear in moments shared over a football match, as recalled by visitors who praise the friendly, attentive service that matches the quality of the food and drink.

Customers consistently highlight the welcoming vibe—from the accommodating staff like Jerry, who effortlessly manage large groups and make each guest feel at home, to bartenders who mix and pour drinks with precision and care. One guest pointed out that even the simple French fries were “darn good,” hinting at the kitchen’s commitment to quality across the board. Another spoke warmly of the place being a great prelude to events at nearby Barclay's Center, thanks to its prime location and inviting atmosphere.

Whether you’re seeking a spirited night out with friends, a cozy spot to enjoy a comforting meal, or a place to catch all the sports action with a perfectly poured beer in hand, McMahon’s Public House stands out as a true Brooklyn gem. Its rich flavors, lively atmosphere, and genuine hospitality make it more than just an Irish pub—it’s a community hub where every visit feels like coming home.

Contact McMahon’s Public House at +1 718-230-4549 to plan your visit or simply drop by and discover for yourself the heartwarming flavors and friendly buzz that have made this pub a staple in Brooklyn’s dining scene.